Jump to content

Single-Ring vs. Two-Ring 2-Stroke Pistons: Which One is Better?


Kevin from Wiseco

Single and dual compression ring two-stroke pistons have been in service for decades, and since their inception, many have wondered if there are advantages to one or the other. If you have been involved with dirt bikes, jet skis, or snowmobiles long enough, you’ve probably noticed different manufacturers have chosen to use one or two compression ring piston designs for their engines. Furthermore, you may have noticed some aftermarket piston companies offer single ring pistons that replace dual ring pistons and vice versa. So, as a consumer, what do these design differences mean, and which one should you choose?

wiseco_single_two_ring_two_stroke-1.JPG.d9dc3f33eb14f28167b1638d53b3ab44.JPG

Wiseco has been manufacturing two-stroke pistons since 1941. In fact, the company started with two-stroke racing pistons being built in Clyde Wiseman’s garage. There’s no replacement for experience, so we want to take this opportunity to shed some light on the advantages and disadvantages of single and dual compression ring two-stroke pistons designs.

Compression Ring Function

We’ll start with a quick review of what a compression ring is designed to do. First and foremost, the compression ring provides a seal that allows the piston to compress the air/fuel mixture as the piston travels upward, then during the combustion event itself, it seals the rapidly expanding hot gases that form during the combustion event. The effectiveness of the compression ring seal, in part, has a significant effect on the power and efficiency of the engine. Should the compression ring lose its ability to seal, the amount of trapped air/fuel mass that will be retained during the compression stroke will be significantly reduced, resulting in less power. Similarly, during the combustion event, a compromised ring seal will allow more gases to leak past the ring, often referred to as blow-by, resulting in reduced power.

wiseco_single_two_ring_two_stroke-11-ps.jpg.9fd57b4328e80bb167dbb0eaf068db63.jpg

The compression ring, or rings, seals compression so the piston can compress the air/fuel mixture. This plays a critical role in performance, as an improper seal will cause a very poor running condition or not allow the engine to run at all.

Heat Transfer

The piston rings play a vital role in transferring heat from the combustion process to the engine's liquid or air cooling systems. During combustion, the piston crown absorbs a portion of the extreme temperatures it is exposed to. If left unregulated, the piston would become so hot that it would melt. Thankfully, the piston rings transfer heat from the piston by connecting the piston to cooler parts of the engine such as the cylinder liner. From the liner, the heat finds its way to the water jacket or to the cooling fins on an air-cooled engine. Engine designers optimize the size, shape, position, and the number of rings to influence how the piston and rings transfer heat.

wiseco_single_two_ring_two_stroke-8-ps.jpg.535aac92d3afad771cee19b4e319985b.jpg

In addition to sealing compression, the piston rings play an important role in transferring heat from the piston crown and through the cylinder wall to be dissipated by the cooling system. Otherwise, the piston material would not survive the extreme heat.

Conformability

The piston ring’s conformability refers to how well it adheres to the shape of the cylinder bore. The conformability of the ring will have a direct effect on how well it seals the mixture and combustion gases as well as transferring heat to the cylinder liner. Factors that influence a ring’s conformability are shape and thickness. In particular, thicker rings will be less conformable than thinner rings because ring thickness has a significant influence on ring stiffness.

wiseco_single_two_ring_two_stroke-9.JPG.5fcb459f73f109dfffd4225d729817e4.JPG

Thicker rings are generally less conformable, and therefore may not seal compression as effectively. However, too thin of a ring will not transfer heat well enough. It's important to develop a balanced ring that performs both tasks effectively.

Wiseco’s Research & Development Manager comments, “Racing applications tend to favor single rings for a lower friction penalty. Also, thinner single rings have better conformability to the cylinder and are less susceptible to flutter at high RPM. Even when specified with lower tension, thinner rings can still have good unit pressure which promotes sealing without a high friction penalty.”

Single Versus Two-Ring Applications

While many have speculated that certain types of two-stroke powered vehicles—whether it be ATVs, dirt bikes, jet skis, or snowmobiles—need one or two ring pistons, it isn’t so much the specific vehicle application that drives the selection, but more the intended use for the vehicle. The big differentiator is whether the vehicle’s intended use is for racing or not. Two-stroke engines designed and developed for racing typically utilize single ring pistons. When designers optimize an engine for racing and select a single compression ring design, several advantages and disadvantages arise when compared to a two-compression ring design. Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of each.

wiseco_single_two_ring_two_stroke-6-ps.jpg.40687cd5261212c7148fef33a27c1967.jpg

A single-ring design is common among Wiseco pistons that are designed for racing and high-performance engines, such as the Racer Elite piston.

Single Ring Pros:

●       Lowest friction design translating to increased power

●       Lowest weight design contributing to fast revving

Single Ring Cons:

●       Potentially less longevity due to heat dispersion

wiseco_single_two_ring_two_stroke-4.JPG.f84154e35c7205596833017a7dba1438.JPG

Two-rings designs are popular among riders that prefer added performance durability at the expense of a little performance. However, some big-bore two-stroke applications benefit more overall from a two-ring design.

Two Ring Pros:

  • Improved heat transfer due to the addition of the second ring
  • Engine performance durability due to 2nd ring’s ability to seal if first ring’s seal becomes compromised

Two Ring Cons: 

  • Increased friction and weight
  • More susceptible to ring flutter at high RPM

“Since a good portion of the piston heat is transferred from the piston to the ring and then to the cooler cylinder wall, one advantage of a 2-ring system is that the second ring would provide a second heat transfer path,” adds Dave Fussner on the topic of two-ring designs.

wiseco_single_two_ring_two_stroke-15-ps.jpg.2ead06219e23bc59963874f321f86ce3.jpg

The last point worth mentioning is that racing piston ring applications are optimized for excellent ring control at high RPM. A condition called “flutter” occurs when a ring becomes unseated from the piston’s ring groove. Flutter occurs around top dead center as the piston transitions from upward motion to downward motion, in part, because the inertia of the ring, which is a function of the ring’s mass, overcomes the gas pressure, pushing the ring against the bottom of the ring groove. When this happens, the ring’s sealing ability is compromised, and engine performance degrades both in terms of performance and durability. Engine designers combat flutter by optimizing the ring's weight so that the ring’s inertia forces cannot induce flutter within the intended RPM range. This is why in many single ring applications the rings are relatively thin.

JE7_7629.jpg.8aa9d6a198e718c8b1ea2f99b8e12638.jpg

Single-ring designs are less susceptible to flutter because there is less ring mass changing direction as the piston begins its return from TDC.

These are the general and major factors that drive single ring and two-ring designs in two-stroke pistons. The intended use of the vehicle usually drives ring selection, not the vehicle type itself. If you are considering a switch from a single ring to a two ring piston, ultimately, how you intend to use your machine should dictate whether the decision  is sensible or not.

wiseco_single_two_ring_two_stroke-2.JPG.d4ea6760e6884c89a0f8768722fec8ad.JPG

wiseco_single_two_ring_two_stroke-2.JPG

  • Like 11
  • Helpful 2


User Feedback

Recommended Comments

Piston rings seal is very much aided by compression and combustion pressures...

The inherent spring tension style of lateral force that a ring exerts on a cylinder wall doesn't stand a chance of sealing combustion pressures on it's own... The ring MUST use combustion pressure to create an effective seal against both the bottom of the ring land AND to force the ring out against the cylinder wall..

The ring and ring channel have to work in unison to allow for gas pressure to get behind the ring to force it out against the cylinder wall... This is what allows the use of lower and lower tension rings... Low tension rings will have less parasitic drag when they don't need to seal tightly, and then have a tight seal when using gas pressure to enhance the downward and outward forces... 

If a secondary ring is the one doing serious pressure retention of any kind, the performance is compromised and the piston's useful hours are on serious decline...

Appreciable pressure captured BELOW the top ring will unseat the top ring from the bottom of the ring groove... Which will then allow for hot gasses to ensconce the top ring... Heat transfer is lost and carbon build up on the bottom of the ring land will make blow bye even worse... And then you have weight and friction of 2 rings, yet only the seal (maybe) of the second ring...

In my experience, if the second ring is the one doing the sealing, you basically don't have a performance engine anymore...

Single ring for me please...

 

  • Helpful 1

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites

The proceeding view point is loosely based on vague recall and seat of the pants experience; no math or science to back it up. 

I prefer the 2 ring piston, if for no other reason, the longevity between top ends.  My 06 CR250R (single ring) would make about 25-30 hours, where as both of my 13 & 14 250SX's would make about 80 hours before needed top end.  Some of this may be due to technology improvements, or simply 2 rings will mask wear for a bit more time.  

As far as the extra ring drag causing HP loss, I have no numbers to dispute such, but I'm guessing the numbers are negligible, or at least at the amateur lever.  Maybe the extra ring seals just a bit better against blow-by, and therefore having a cleaner base for the next incoming air-fuel charge.

I raced dirt cars for years before venturing into the world of Mx, and we used and had excellent results with Total Seal rings.  I contacted Total Seal about making a total seal ring for a 2-stroke.  They said they would look into it if I would send them the cylinder and piston, but I never followed through.

I reckon I'm done babbling/meandering, thanks for listening. 

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites

In the 50,s it was not seldom that a 2 stroke piston had 3 rings.

That was at a time when cast iron cylinders and lousy Piston and ring material needed big over bores.To stabelise the piston against the walls , 3 rings were better then less.

Today,with Nicasil plating , phantastik oil,s we can manage with one single ring for a very long time.

This little air cooled 125 SCREAMER runs on NICASIL-Single RING and 100-1 (Opti2) at least one full season ( before it may need a new ring.)

Zunny 003.jpg

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites
On 12/7/2018 at 2:23 PM, Antoine Mion said:

Interesting post. 

What if I want my 2 rings piston become a single ring one? I guess I would have to keep the top ring.

Yes, you would have to keep the top ring. But it's always recommended to only run them as they were designed. It would only be recommended to buy a single-ring piston specifically if that's what you're looking for.

  • Like 2

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites

OK, thanks ! Of course, it would only be in case I cannot find a single ring one. For example, I have a 125 TSR Suzuki, for this one, you only find 2 rings pistons. I want to try some scavenging changes and the 2nd ring gets into my way.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting.  Here is what I wonder . . . I have a 1973 DT-3 250 Yamaha.  I have a NEW Nos Standard Piston and rings (Part #Piston 438-11631-01-96, Rings 311-11610-00-00).  Of course base, head and exhaust gaskets are new too, along with the connecting rod/pin cir-clips.  I am about to hone the cylinder and reassemble.  But could I have gone with a NEW Wiseco piston and rings, even if in the single ring configuration versus my stock double ring setup?  Then I would not be getting old brittle rings.  I did NOT see a NEW Piston/Rings aftermarket anywhere for my Yamaha.  Good article.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites
On 3/18/2019 at 7:41 AM, claventure33 said:

Interesting.  Here is what I wonder . . . I have a 1973 DT-3 250 Yamaha.  I have a NEW Nos Standard Piston and rings (Part #Piston 438-11631-01-96, Rings 311-11610-00-00).  Of course base, head and exhaust gaskets are new too, along with the connecting rod/pin cir-clips.  I am about to hone the cylinder and reassemble.  But could I have gone with a NEW Wiseco piston and rings, even if in the single ring configuration versus my stock double ring setup?  Then I would not be getting old brittle rings.  I did NOT see a NEW Piston/Rings aftermarket anywhere for my Yamaha.  Good article.

No, unfortunately we don't have any pistons on the shelf for that model. Custom pistons are always an option if you want to explore that in the future, but there are minimum quantities depending on the order.

  • Like 1

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites


Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • Similar Content

    • By codywood806
      What's going on everyone? My name is Cody and I thought I would post my RMX 250 supermoto build trials and tribulations in a hope to help anyone in the future who may also go down this path. I know I am not the first to post this build on the forum, but I definitely ran into problems that may shed some light onto your future projects. 
      First things first, thank you to the many forum members who helped me along the way... Especially during the electrical.  
      Alright, now to the build. This build definitely falls under the budget category of SM builds. All together I have roughly $2000 into the conversion. 
      Starting with the electrical setup, this was the most difficult part. There was many a times that I was coming to the forum to get some answers. Floating the ground is the first part to getting the system switched to DC. This is accomplished by cutting the ground wire from the stator lighting coil and running it directly up to your new rectifier/regulator.


      I also disconnected the frame ground at the ignition coil (Black/White wire on the right post of the coil).

      The rec/reg that I am using is the Trail Tech Universal model (https://www.rockymountainatvmc.com/parts/trail-tech-universal-voltage-regulator-rectifier-p). I wired the rec/reg with the grey wire from one side of the stator lighting coil and the new black wire that I soldered on and ran through the harness. The new rec/reg was mounted in the stock location on the frame right below the seat. Next, I connected an AGM battery for simplicity of charging. Honestly, I would go with an alternative lithium or nickel metal setup and bite the bullet on the charger. If you are curious though, the battery that fits perfectly into the air box of the RMX is a Duracell Ultra 1.3 AH (https://www.batteriesplus.com/productdetails/slaa12=1.3f). My final wiring that I was happy with used deutsch connectors for all removable components. Don't mind the ugly wiring on the battery in the picture below. 

      Now that the 12V DC system is established, I could get the lighting kit but together. The lighting kit that I went with is the Tusk kit from RM (https://www.rockymountainatvmc.com/parts/tusk-motorcycle-enduro-lighting-kit-p). I ended up cutting a lot of the runs, trimming them to size, and then soldering them back up. Took a lot of time but well worth the clean look in the end. Everything was covered in loom and then the loom was wrapped with tesa tape. The Tusk kit is what you would expect for a ~$180 lighting kit. The main control switch is a little cheap but at the end of the day it gets the job done. One thing you will want to purchase is another brake pressure switch for your front brakes to activate the brake light as well. The ONE provided pressure switch fits the rear, however you will need the BREMBO switch for the front... (https://www.rockymountainatvmc.com/parts/tusk-hydraulic-brake-switch-brembo-brakes-p?s=212720) I had to learn that the hard way. 

      Later on I also decided to just replace the front light with a DOT certified unit. Don't worry l held onto the stock one, but I wanted to be 100% legal as far as lights go. Ended up picking  this one from RM, (https://www.rockymountainatvmc.com/parts/polisport-mmx-headlight-p?s=194673) I'd say it doesn't look too bad. I connected the running light to the tail light circuit in the Tusk light harness so it is always on when the harness power is on. 

      I finished up the electrical setup with a simple Trail Tech Vapor for tach/speedo. The install was pretty straight forward. The only challenges that I ran into was with the coolant temp sensor and the unit staying on while revving. For the install of the coolant sensor I had to shave a small amount off of each radiator neck so that the sensor could fit between. A little ghetto but it does the job and no leaks over many rides since. For the revving issue it was a simple fix that took forever to figure it out. Not even Trail Tech could solve it. The unit would stay on but as soon as I would rev the engine it would freak out and shut off. The fix was throwing in a spark plug with resistor. BR8ES. Works like a charm. I also slapped together a simple switched ignition. Simple 2 wire ignition switch that interrupts the signal from the CDI to the coil (Blue/White wire on ignition coil). Again, ignore the ugly wiring on the left side of the frame. Was loomed and taped for protection against the abrasion between the frame and tank. 

      Now for the fun part, the wheels! So I thought... I bought the hubs off of ebay for $25 and $50. This is what they looked like when I started.

      Stripped them down and pulled the old bearings. Then I sanded and sanded and sanded. Started with dremel (80 grit? attachment), 120, 220, 400, 800, 1500, 0000 steel wool. Final polish with mothers mag/aluminum polish.

      The rims are Warp 9 Elites. I am pretty dang happy with them. They are a great budget option if you don't want to shell out for Excel, Sun, etc... I went with the 36-hole/4.25 Silver SM rim for the rear. For the front I did the 36-hole/3.5 Silver SM rim. 

      (Dang cats.... He was just as excited to see them as I was!)
      The next part is where I made my biggest mistake. I decided to be a cheap ass and have all the components sent to me and trust a local shop to assemble them (avoiding shipping costs). The spokes I purchased from Buchanan's Spoke and Rim located in Southern California. Their customer service was great. I called them and told them what I was building, gave them rim size and nipple size and they did the rest. The local shop that was supposed to assemble the wheels jerked me over for 5 weeks, laced the rear wheel and failed to get the front together. Both wheels were scratched to piss. Lesson learned... Trust the pros. I ended up shipping everything back to Buchanan's, which I should have done in the first place. They did a killer job and no added scratches. 10/10 would recommend their services to anyone. If I did it again, I would have shipped the hubs to Buchanan's and had Warp 9 send the rims to Buchanan's, would have saved $100 in shipping + $145 for a failed lace and scratch job.

      Ended up ordering the Tusk brake rotors for the front and rear and they look great and work as expected. I wish there was a big brake kit available, but I don't know of any available. I also decided to go tubeless for the wheel setup. I followed to a T, "Jake the Garden Snake's" video on it: 
      I purchased all the same tape and valve stems and it turned out awesome. Super pumped on it. For the gearing I went with a 44 on the rear and a 14 on the front. For bolts and hardware I used Tusk rotor bolt kits and I would recommend staying away from them. Just snugging them down with a little German torque started to round them out. The metal they use is pretty soft. Finally, for tires I went with Bridgestone Battlax Hypersport S20 Evos (140/70/17 - Rear) (110/70/17 - Front). They are sticky enough and stupid cheap right now (March 2020) with RM Bridgestone rebate (https://www.rockymountainatvmc.com/l/2020-Bridgestone-Mar-Apr-Rebate-Info?il_medium=main-bridgestone-2020-mar-apr-rebate&il_source=home). I would recommend sticking with the 140 rear. Many people will go with a 150 and have rubbing issues with the chain. Keep it simple, especially for a simple hoolagin bike. 
      Here is the final product. I am super stoked on it and think it turned out great for not breaking the bank. Let me know if you guys have any questions. I hope this helped some people along their journey and/or motivated you to begin. Thank you for taking the time to read my post.
      Ride hard,
      Cody.
    • By Jacob Leszczuk
      Wondering if anyone can recommend a good 2-stroke oil? Just picked up a beautiful YZ250 and it’s my first two stroke so I’m not really sure on what’s good in regards to smoker premix juice 😝
    • By Burke Moore
      I am going to take apart the top end of my 2005 Yamaha Yz85 to asses some damage. This will be my first time taking apart the top end of a two stroke. From videos I have watched, it looks like a need to take off the header, the gas tank. and the radiator. Does any body have any suggestions on what order I should take these things off in? Any other tips on two stroke top ends would be helpful!
    • By Sendit95
      Need to know if a 95 jug will bolt onto a 96 block and perform correctly can’t get answer anywhere! Please and thanks .

    • By Chadkschmidt
      Hey guys,
      i just picked up an 07 Ktm 250 XC-F for $400 and it needs a full motor rebuild. The piston broke and smashed a couple valves, put a hole in the jug, and bent/broke the rod. Huge job. If I were to buy the parts from KTM, I’d have to sell a kidney to afford it. I’m having trouble finding the parts I need. Does anyone have experience with this and could advise me? Could a machine shop do any work on this or do I need all new parts? Do any models have shared parts with this bike? Like would a SX jug work with the XCF? Anybody have one they’re looking to part out? 
       
      I know there’s a lot of questions there haha. If you have any insight or suggestions, I’d greatly appreciate it! Thanks!
×
×
  • Create New...