Jump to content
ONLY 36 HOURS LEFT! Read more... ×
Sign in to follow this  

Snell vs. BSI 6658 Type A Helmet Testing Comparison


bultaco

1. What is BSI?

a. BSI is one of the largest and most prestigious standards, quality assurance, inspection, testing and certification organizations in the world. Similar to the familiar UL Listing, the BSI offers testing and rating services for major manufactures with worldwide distribution interests. The BSI Inspectorate is a leading provider of inspection, analysis and testing services across the globe. A vital business within the BSI Group, BSI Inspectorate delivers confidence for buyers and sellers alike, as well as banks and governments involved in international trade the world over.

2. I heard that all of Europe has opted for the EC 22-05; does this mean that the BS 6658 Type A is no longer valid?

a. While a number of helmet manufacturers have opted for a single unifying standard for Europe (EC22-05) for economies of manufacture, BSI are still operating the Kitemark certification scheme for BS 6658 Type A, Type AF and Type B helmets and the helmets we import will continue to bear the prestigious BS 6658 Type A Kitemark.

3. You say that these helmets are "Batch Tested", what does this mean?

a. BSI testing is done in a "pre public release" fashion. When the manufacturer has produced a product "batch" of helmets, say 500 to 2000 units, and samples of that particular batch are sampled by a BSI representative and randomly tested at the BSI testing facilities - 5 for a production batch of 500, 13 for a batch of 501-1,200 and 20 for batches of 1,201-2000. Each production batch must be of the same model. Only after each of the helmets have passed a battery of specified tests are the BSI serialized decals then released for that specific batch and in that specific quantity.

4. What happens if there is a performance failure during one of these tests?

a. Should any helmet fail any test, the entire batch is rejected and samples must be submitted for retest, following investigation of the problem and remedial action. This helps to insure that every helmet that could ultimately be worn by the end user came from a batch of helmets that was certified to comply with the standard. (Source: http://www.bsi-global.com/index.xalter )

5. How does this compare with Snell's "post public release" testing?

a. With the Snell post public release testing program you find a random testing of helmets purchased off dealers shelves. If a helmet fails the random tests, the manufacturer is notified of the discrepancy and more random tests are performed. Should a manufacturer show repetitive failures, discussions are had between Snell and the manufacturer on ways to come back into compliance. Potentially, the manufacturer could loose their certification status. However, this sampling can be as low as four thousandth of one percent (.004%) of annual helmets sold for the higher volume manufacturers. In one example, only 16 helmets were tested of an approximate 400,000 helmets sold of one particular manufacturer in 2001 (Source: Ed Becker, Executive Director Snell Memorial Foundation: http://www.smf.org/). While this is within the "up to 2%" Snell states in their literature, it is quite obvious that in actuality, the BSI pre public release compliance testing is magnitudes more likely to catch defective helmets before they ever leave the factory floor, while the Snell system is simply much less likely to catch defective helmets or fraudulent manufacturers. The result can be helmets available to the riding public manufactured to comply with the Snell 2000 and DOT standards may not always do so. (Reference: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, DOT Performance Compliance Test results: http://www.nhtsa.dot...s218/index.html) This is a critical safety issue.

6. In addition to pre-public release batch testing, what does the BSI require of manufacturers to ensure only high quality products are made available to the public?

a. After each helmet model and shell size has passed original specifications and compliance tests and awarded BS 6658 Type A approval, there is an annual re-certification, and quarterly factory inspections for quality control. No other standards available in the USA offer this level of quality control.

7. Some helmet manufactures state that their helmets pass the BSI 6658 Type A standard in addition to Snell. How can I be sure that the helmet I am buying is BSI 6658 Type A approved?

a. While it is common for manufacturers to build helmet models to meet different standards around the world, due to the unique specifications each standard dictates, there is no assurance that any one build for any particular model would be approved by more than one standard with out being tested to that standard; only helmets bearing the serialized BSI blue Kite Mark are BSI 6658 Type A approved. With out this label, there has been no pre public release batch testing by the BSI and as such the BSI will not recognize it as passing the standard.

8. What does the Type A mean and how does it differ from a non type A helmet?

a. The Type A designation means that it meets the more severe impact criteria that is required to be recognized as race approved by the FIM, AMA, FORMULA-USA, WERA etc. and all other major racing organizations and race clubs in the USA.

9. Is it true that Suomy BSI certified helmets are over 300 grams lighter than the Suomy helmet certified to the Snell standard and if so, why?

a. Yes! A BSI certified Suomy helmet might be as much as 300 grams lighter than it's Snell counterpart (we manufacture OEM helmets for Ducati and Aprilia to the Snell standard). The difference is merited out of the variances between the two standards protocols. These testing protocols may vary in such ways as head form weight, falling mass, measurements such as the distance velocity is measured above the impact site, velocity at point of impact and drop heights. The significant deviation between Snell and the BSI Type A is in the second drop height, with Snell's second drop being higher than BSI's second drop (most experts will agree that the second impact drop height for Snell is not relevant to motorcycling but reflects the particular demands of auto racing where the driver's head may impact a roll cage several times during a crash). This differentiation results in a lighter, less rigid outer shell requirement to pass the demanding BSI 6658 Type A test. This decrease in shell rigidity allows the helmet to work in concert with the EPS system (expanded polystyrene) to better mitigate energies experienced at speeds where the rigid shell of the Snell configuration can fall short, without compromising the fundamental energy management of much higher energy loads. A helmet that performs to the standard at the lightest possible weight reduces total pivoting mass, head deceleration and will tire rider less, thus increasing safety. In addition, lighter helmets are more likely to be worn and wearing one is the single critical factor in the prevention of and reduction in head injury. (Source: The HURT Report Summary, Line #45 - www.cs.wisc.edu/~john/vfr/hurt.html University Of Wisconsin).

10. If the BSI standard is so good, why not simply build the helmet to meet both the BSI 6658 Type A and Snell 2000 standard as well, and avoid any confusion?

a. As mentioned above, the major deviation between the two standards in found in the second drop height. This requirement forces the manufacturer to build a much stiffer outer shell to perform well in the Snell 2000 second drop impact tests. This stiffer shell requirement may also prevent the helmet from passing the BSI 6658 Type A standard, by not allowing the helmet to start absorbing energy until a much higher threshold. By not allowing the helmet to begin managing energy at the typical speeds and energies a rider is most likely to experience, the Snell 2000 is counter intuitive to the BSI 6658 Type A.

11. What is the essential difference between the mandatory DOT standard and the voluntary standards such as Snell and BSI 6658 Type A?

a. While there are several significant differences between the DOT standard and other voluntary standards, the key difference has to do with something called "Dwell Time". Dwell Time is best expressed as the duration in time above a pre-determined deceleration that the head, or brain is experiencing during impact. The DOT specification calls out a maximum allowable deceleration of 400g from a drop height of 1.8 meters with sustained energies above 200g to not exceed 2 milliseconds and 4 milliseconds above 150g. This energy duration, or dwell time, is an important consideration in preventing brain injuries at the anticipated energies a rider might experience in a fall. Both BSI 6658 Type A and Snell 2000 require a maximum deceleration of 300g, (a 100 G force reduction) but have no "dwell time" component built into the standard. However, it is important to note that while neither BSI Type A, nor Snell 2000 have a dwell time component, each standard MUST pass the DOT 218 dwell time requirement to be considered legal for street use in the USA.

12. How well do Snell and BSI Type A helmets comply with this Dwell Time requirement?

a. Suomy helmets built to the BSI 6658 Type A standard perform extremely well in the Dwell Time test, while helmets built to Snell 2000 may not perform as well due to the stiffer outer shell the standard mandates. Due to Snell's post public release testing and for reasons previously mentioned above, some helmets manufactured to the Snell standard may not pass the DOT compliance test (Reference . National Highway Traffic Safety Administration .

DOT Performance Compliance Test results: http://www.nhtsa.dot...218/index.html). However, with the BSI pre factory release batch testing, helping to ensure compliance, a DOT failure is highly unlikely.

13. I understand that BSI 6658 Type A and Snell M2000 are the only nationally recognized racing standards in the USA. But I don't race. Is a Snell or BSI Type A certified helmet safer than a DOT certified helmet for my street riding?

a. While the Snell standard is recognized by the general public as superior to DOT for the racing community, many experts believe that a helmet manufactured to the DOT standard is actually safer for street riding than a helmet manufactured specifically to the Snell standard. At first Glance this might seem illogical, after all if Snell is good enough for racers than it must be better for street riders, right? This is not always the case! With the Median motorcycle street accident being just 29.8 MPH prior to impact, (Source . The HURT Report Summary, Line #15 - http://www.cs.wisc.e...n/vfr/hurt.html University Of Wisconsin), and many impacts being a glancing blow to the side of the head, a typical Snell certified helmet might not experience ENOUGH energy to properly dissipate the energy being transmitted to the head (this is a result of the heavier and stiffer outer shell that the higher Snell second drop on a hemi anvil requires). This may result in unnecessary concussion or head injury. Suomy helmets built to the demanding BSI Type A standard have built in features that provide for extremely favorable DOT test performance as well as the more demanding requirements of the BSI Type A standard, and each Suomy BSI certified helmet is batch tested for performance compliance prior to public release to help ensure that your Suomy BSI 6658 Type A approved helmet passes both the BSI test as well as the mandatory DOT tests.

1. You mention that many helmet impacts are a "glancing blow" to the side of the head. How do BSI and Snell test for this important and common type of impact?

a. The BSI 6658 Type A utilizes two unique impact energy management tests to ensure the helmet will perform when asked to. In the first test the helmet is impacted against a bar anvil to assess projections from the general shape of the shell and in the second test the helmet is impacted against an abrasive pad. These tests are utilized to ensure that the helmet will not have any design features that could catch and twist the rider.s neck. Interestingly, Snell does not test for either of these Oblique Impacts.

2. When asked if lower priced Snell helmets are as safe as their more expensive counterparts, Ed Becker of Snell responded, "My feeling is they are", (Source - Laurie Watanabe, Dealer News January 2001 article "Snell Game"). Many helmet manufacturers disagree and state that their premium helmets perform much better at deceleration below 300g than the less expensive counterparts. They are demanding a tiered performance certification depending on how well the helmets do at managing energy. My question is what is Suomy's response to these claims?

a. In testing for deceleration, the key test to helmet performance, the results are clear and irrefutable. We are unhappy that something so precise as helmet deceleration performance, analysis and the organization that has built its reputation on analytical examination has diluted the answer of this important and direct question down to a "feeling". But it goes farther. In addition to this legitimate concern, many premium manufacturers complain that high volume low priced helmets are not sampled (post public release) to the same percentages for performance compliance than the higher quality, lower volume premium helmets. It has been suggested that if Snell enforced and tested a standard percentage of helmets produced by each manufacturer many of these so-called Snell certified helmets would not be able to maintain the standard. (Source: Arthur Domagala, Motorcycle Industry Magazine, December 2002 Issue article "Are All Snell Helmets Created Equal"). All BSI certified helmets are all pre public release batch certified to the same percentage for each batch size ensuring equality for all manufacturers seeking BSI 6658 Type A certification.

3. You've made a strong case for BSI for the USA market. Why is Suomy the only major brand to import their helmets to this exacting and equitable standard?

a. This is a very good question. Maybe because Suomy is a pioneer in helmet development and rider safety and not afraid to take the better, if not beaten path. Finally, our case is simple; we have available to us a standard that complies with the mandatory DOT performance requirements, is approved by every major motorcycle racing organization, offers better quality controls and we believe a statistically safer helmet for all riders, whether it by for the street or track. Knowing this, how could we NOT take this option? Maybe you should ask your favorite manufacturer why their helmets are not produced to the BSI 6658 Type A standard.

For further reading for insights into helmet standards and their perceptions in the marketplace, please see the following articles; Laurie Watanabe, Dealer News January 2001 article "Snell Game" - Kris Slawinski, Motorcycle Product News, March 2001 article "Snell : Gold Standard or Old Standard" . Marc Cook, Motorcyclist Magazine June 2002 article "The Real World: Six Critical Facts About Helmets" - Lance Oliver, American Motorcyclist June 2002 article "Hat Tricks" - Arthur Domagala, Motorcycle Industry Magazine, December 2002 Issue article "Are All Snell Helmets Created Equal?".

See also the following references:

BSI - . http://www.bsi-global.com/index.xalter

Snell Memorial Foundation - http://www.smf.org/

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration . DOT Performance Compliance Test results: http://www.nhtsa.dot...s218/index.html

The HURT Report Summary - www.cs.wisc.edu/~john/vfr/hurt.html

Head Protection Research laboratory - http://www.hprl.org

Re: "A New Helmet Standard" CYCLE WORLD MAGAZINE October 2002 page 34

Sign in to follow this  


User Feedback

Recommended Comments

There are no comments to display.



Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Reply with:


  • Similar Content

    • By Bryan Bosch
      Any powersport enthusiast has hundreds, if not THOUSANDS of dollars worth of protective equipment. The Helmet Butler helps to protect and increase the life of your safety equipment by properly storing it. Jackets that are hung improperly can have stretched and worn areas which can lead to tears and weak spots. A simple 3 foot fall off the seat of a motorcycle can render any helmet useless in the event of a crash. Whether you are done riding for the day or the season, your equipment deserves proper storage. The Helmet Butler is made with pride in the USA by powersport enthusiasts just like you! Help insure that your equipment is stored properly and safely by using the Helmet Butler today!
       
      Installation Video

       
      Product Demo

    • By MXEditor
      PRODUCT DESCRIPTION
       
      The Sena SMH10R is a feature packed Bluetooth 3.0 stereo headset system for your helmet that allows you to:
       
      Connect to your Bluetooth enabled devices like cell phone
      Initiate and receive telephone calls via voice activation
      Conduct intercom conversations in full duplex with other riders.
      Listen to music from your phone or via streaming live
      Listen to GPS navigation instructions
      Share music among the intercom group
      Talk to passengers also equipped
       
      Here’s what you get. Upon opening up the boxes we inventoried the contents and everything you need to install and get up and running is included. We received two small speakers, two microphones (button mic for full-face helmets, boom mic for open-face helmets), rechargeable battery pack and the Bluetooth unit which mount on the exterior of the helmet as well as all the Velcro mounting hardware required.
    • By Bryan Bosch
      The 20S, Sena’s newest motorcycle and powersports Bluetooth communication system, will revolutionize the way you ride. Boasting several industry firsts, the 20S uses Bluetooth 4.0 technology with dual Bluetooth communication modules, creating one of the most advanced Bluetooth headsets in the market today. The 20S has incorporated Audio Multitasking which allows you to converse with others while simultaneously listening to music or GPS applications. These audio features will not interrupt each other but will simply overlay for an overall smooth listening experience, not to mention allowing users to share music with other riders, all while talking and riding.
       
      A huge jump in the tech and gadget world is the 20S’ multi-way conference intercom which gives riders the ability to intercom with up to eight users simultaneously for up to a 1.2 mile radius. Enhanced with HD quality voice technologies, users are now free to create a joint riding experience with their fellow riders. Users can even use the impressive 20S smartphone app to manage and connect these intercom groups with just one touch, as well as set up the device and personalize their settings straight from their iPhone or Android.
       
      Safety comes first with Sena and is exemplified through the 20S’ motion sensor and voice command abilities. A simple shake of the device will turn on reliable connectivity and provide easier setup and pairing. Voice commands allow riders to operate audio functions and intercom features without needing to take their hands off the handlebars and ensure safe, hands free control.
       
      With a sleek new body design, the Sena 20S is an all-in-one audio kit, offering dual audio ports for both speakers and ear buds in an all-inclusive clamp. This allows for easier helmet mounting and more flexible switch capabilities. A dual microphone is also available, one on the clamp to detect environmental sounds without the hassle of taking off the helmet, and one inside the helmet for intercom function, thus enhancing the entire riding experience.
       
      The new 20S by Sena transforms communication between riders on the road and offers a new and improved way to enjoy the journey ahead. With so many high-tech advances all in one single device, the 20S only solidifies Sena as an innovator in not only the technology world, but in the motorcycle and powersports community.
       
      Features



      - Bluetooth 4.0
      - Dual Bluetooth module communication system
      - Audio Multitasking™
      - Multi-way intercom up to 8 connections
      - Group Intercom™
      - Bluetooth intercom up to 2.0 kilometers (1.2 miles)*
      - Smartphone App for iPhone and Android
      - Universal Intercom™
      - Advanced Noise Control™
      - Intuitive voice prompts and voice commands
      - HD quality crystal clear and natural sound
      - Bluetooth Audio Recording™
      - Versatile functions using motion sensor technology
      - All-in-one helmet clamp kit- Built-in FM radio tuner with a station scan and save function
      - Bluetooth pairing for dual mobile phones
      - Bluetooth handsfree for Bluetooth mobile phones
      - Bluetooth stereo headset for Bluetooth audio devices such as MP3 players
      - Bluetooth stereo headset for Bluetooth GPS navigations
      - Firmware upgradeable

      * in open terrain
       
      To learn more about this product, visit the Sena Website.
       

    • By Bryan Bosch
      The scala rider G9x unit allows Bluetooth intercom communication between 9 riders at a remarkable distance of 1 mile/1.6 km. Connectivity to mobile phones, GPS, MP3 and built-in FM radio. Cardo SmartSet App for unit customization on-the-go.
       
      The scala rider G9x is your social network in motion allowing you to connect via voice command to 8 additional riders within a range of 1 mile/1.6 Km*. Riding as a small group? Have a 4-way full-duplex intercom conferencing call. With the G9x, pairing is fast and easy: simply ‘bump two G9x units together and you’re ready to hit the road.
      The G9x you can always stay connected: pair your G9x via Bluetooth with up to two mobile phones simultaneously and talk hands-free. Want to listen to music? Stream it via A2DP from your smartphone or MP3 and listen together with a passenger to the same tunes using the Music-Sharing™ feature. You can also connect to your GPS and enjoy the built in FM radio.
       
      Keep your G9x in forefront of technology via Cardo Community® social web platform. When on-the-go, customize settings using the Cardo SmartSet app, available free for Android and iOS mobile devices.
       
      Enjoy the ride!
       
      *Results may vary according to terrain
       
    • By yz250f_spud
      The SMH5-FM is a Bluetooth 3.0 stereo headset with Bluetooth intercom and built-in FM tuner designed specifically for motorcycles. With the SMH5-FM, you can call handsfree on your Bluetooth mobile phone, listen to stereo music or voice instructions of GPS navigations by Bluetooth wirelessly, and have two-way intercom conversations in full duplex with a passenger or other motorcycle riders.Thanks to the latest Bluetooth 3.0 and the advanced digital signal processing technology, the SMH5-FM offers the best sound quality for both incoming and outgoing sound in its class. Also, the easy-to-access and intuitive button operations make the SMH5-FM a perfect companion for motorcycles.
       
      Features
       

       
          Bluetooth 3.0     Bluetooth intercom up to 700 meters (760 yards)*     Built-in FM radio tuner with station scan and save function     Bluetooth Multi-pair intercom up to 4 people     Universal Intercom     Music sharing     Multipoint Bluetooth for dual mobile phone     Voice prompts     Bluetooth stereo headset for Bluetooth audio devices such as MP3 players     Bluetooth music playback control by AVRCP     Easy operation by versatile Jog Dial (Patent acquired)     Sufficient sound level with integrated audio booster     Bluetooth handsfree for Bluetooth mobile phones     Bluetooth headset or stereo headset for Bluetooth GPS navigations     Speed dialing     Sidetone     Water resistant for use in inclement weather     Crystal clear and natural sound quality     Advanced Noise Control     Up to 7 hours talk time, 6 days stand-by time     Can be used while charging on road trips     Individual volume control for each audio source     Firmware upgradeable     Peace of mind – thanks to the two-year warranty
      * in open terrain
×