CRF vs XR for dual purpose

I'm looking for a potent dirt bike, yet be able to make it street legal. Does anyone know the torque and weight difference between a CRF X and a XR R


I don't know about torque but thay feel about 35lbs different.

What would you say is the biggest difference?

Pound for pound the 450X is lighter. And it feels it. And it has electric start.

The 650R has more torque. There isn't a mainstream dirtbike in production that has as much bottom end torque as the 650R. But you pay for it with weight.

If dualsporting them, the 650R will be way more comfortable at speeds of 75mph+ than the X. Not that the X can't do it, it can, but it is just not as "comfy" as the R when pounding pavement.

It depends what is most important to you. I ride 450X's all the time as most of my friends and family have them. But I still keep my 650R because I am willing to put up with the weight to have that kind of power at my disposal.

It may be tough, but you really need to find an example of each to take for a short spin to decide which way to go is better for you. Most people will ride both and then go with the X. The lower weight and the "button" usually wins over the power and girth every time!

An XR650R would be a handful if you plan to ride it the woods of the eastern United States.

for street use the XR is a better choice. for dirt use the 450X is a better choice. (40+ pounds lighter is a big difference)

the XR will take less to maintain, and in the long run cost you less to operate.

the 450X is an amazing machine that will provide you with endless fun.

I am lucky enough to be able to have both, so I don't have to choose.:D

Thanks for all the advice, how much more maintenance is the 450 X over the 650 R

Do you have run high octane gas for the 450 X

Thanks for all the advice, how much more maintenance is the 450 X over the 650 R

Do you have run high octane gas for the 450 X



- slower revving engine

- power curve starts at idle and stops early (compared to an X)

- you can literally ride it in any gear if you want

- top heavy, wide

- stock carb is NOT friendly when dropped, cold weather, rapid WOT

- very, very low maintenence top end

- holds a good amount of engine/tranny oil (infrequent oil changes)

- limited suspension, unless you add cubic dollars (for intense off-road


- incredibly fun at less-than-race speed in the tight stuff

- incredibly stable at race speeds in the wide open stuff

- extremely not fun if dropped on a steep hill !


- very, very quick reving engine (compared to an XR)

- can be made incredibly fast for relatively low dollars (R parts, uncork)

- Exceptional suspension, with plenty of room for growth

- tiny engine oil capacity (under 700cc) requiring more frequent changing

- more highly stressed top end (if treating well, is pretty reliable)

- top end can be abused more easily, resulting in more frequent top end

service. This can mostly be avoided by maintenence and not hitting the rev

limiter (ever).

- did I mention the incredible suspension?

- a joyful motor to behold: amazing throttle response and power

- very wide range of tuning options for the motor (monster torque, to


- stiff and uncomfortable for extended street riding

I've had both. I sold the XR.

Last post somes it all very well. You just need to be honest with yourself on what you want to do.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By cmckay4
      Anyone having or had problems with the starter not turning over easily on the 450X???
      I have read about this problem on CRF's ONLY and not seen anyone come up with a fix.
      Problem being is that you think there is a problem with the battery, when infact the battery is OK. When you have a good fully charged battery in the bike and press the e-start, it turns over very slowly.
      I have checked the electrical circuit and it seems OK. I am wondering if it might be the starter itself - any suggestions?????
    • By Dust_Devil
      I'll start, if you see the "Fox Sticker" out in the Dez you know you crossed paths with ol' DD.....

    • By JohnnyAirtime

      Guys and Gals...
      Post your links to any of your pictures in this thread....
      (proper placement of pictures is in the "picture" threads)
      Post your links to any of your ride reports in this thread....
      (proper placement of your ride reports is relative to the area you live/ride)
      NO TECHNICAL issues, questions or comments in this thread.
      (it'll be deleted to keep this thread clean and with only the above listed).

      Please follow this format;
      Ride Report: Gorman, Tuesday 4-17
      (by Skoot22)
      Pictures from Ride: Baja 4.14.07
      (by Johnnyairtime)
    • By dakynz
      Guys, because of a member ban the jetting database has been removed. Let's start a new one to get this great information created into a sticky for everyone's benefit. Please stick to the information below.
      Temperature Range:
      Smog (AIS):
      Airbox Modified Top:
      Airbox Modified Sides:
      Backfire Screen:
      Air Filter:
      Pilot Jet:
      Main Jet:
      Needle Clip Position:
      Fuel Screw Type:
      Fuel Screw Setting:
      AP Modified:
      Leak Jet:
      AP Cover:
      Exhaust Type:
      Exhaust Modified:
      Pink Wire Modified:
    • By 2can
      I've studied the Jetting sticky's but still have a number of questions:
      I bought my '06 a couple of years ago and had a smog block-off kit installed and the pilot jet was upsized to a 48 and the air box opened up top only. The bike has appeared to run a little lean at times and got hot on a couple of occasions in elevation and on one other occasion. I'm looking at upping the main jet to either a 165 or 170 to help with the possible lean condition. The bike currently has a 142 main jet in it which I believe is the stock size. It looks like the most widely used Needle Jets are the JD Red, but it doesn't look like they are sold separately, is this correct?
      I was going to also get a 45 pilot to have options for further tuning. My assumption is that every bike is a little different and that where you ride is going to have a lot to do with jetting. We ride mostly, mojave desert, baja, and southern Utah with elevations from sea level to 9,000 feet but the higher elevations are generally for a short period as we generally continue through the peaks and head back down.
      I'm looking to convert from a stock exhaust to possibly an FMF Q4. I want something a little throatier but not overly loud and will provide a balanced flow of intake/exhaust.
      So can I get the JD Red Needle Jet by itself or can I get by using the stock and move the clip and be just as happy. I'm just looking to enhance overall performance of the engine and maintain reliability.